0:00
Let me ask you something. How safe do you feel in your own home? And how sure are you that you'd notice if something
0:06
was off? Something as simple as a door opening, a footstep in the hallway, or a
0:12
presence that didn't belong? Do you think that you'd recognize that danger in time? Or would it move quietly around
0:18
you while you slept soundly at night? On November the 13th, 2022, those questions
0:24
stopped being hypothetical when four university students were murdered inside their own home in Moscow, Idaho. At the
0:31
time, they were living just off campus in a place that was meant for rest, studying, and safety.
0:38
And what followed forced a community and then an entire nation to face one of the most horrifying and notorious cases of
0:45
2022. Welcome, or welcome back to Copy House Crime, folks. My name is Adrian
0:51
and today we're heading to Moscow, Idaho to look at a case that eventually became known as the Idaho 4. And I'll be honest
0:57
with you here, the more that you dig at this case, the more that it seems to unravel. In fact, there are many details
1:03
that I didn't even know about until I started researching this one. By the way, here is a quick reminder that I and
1:09
the rest of my team at Coffee House Crime are all in fact humans and we don't present with AI. We do have a cat
1:14
though named Nero, so subscribe for Nero or of course to support your favorite YouTubers. We really do appreciate it.
1:21
Thank you. Now then, with that said, let's get down to the usual. Please grab yourself a coffee and let's caffeinate
1:26
while we investigate. This is the case of the Idaho 4.
1:40
Welcome to Moscow, Idaho, folks. with a population of just over 25,000
1:45
residents. Moscow is inseparable from the University of Idaho. When I say that, what I mean is that the university
1:52
isn't simply in the town, but it is quite literally Moscow's pulse. As for
1:57
its students, Moscow feels safe. Violent crime is rare enough to feel abstract,
2:02
and when something bad happens, it tends to be elsewhere to other people. Houses near campus blur into social spaces.
2:10
Friends come and go and doors are routinely left unlocked. It's the kind of place where noise complaints are the
2:16
most likely police visit and where life feels like one long social event day in
2:21
and day out. Now on King Road, which is a short walk away from campus and found
2:26
on the southwest corner of town, was a threestory rental house that stood like many others. As you may have already
2:33
guessed, this was just another usual run-of-the-mill student house. cheap and cheerful and filled with six young
2:40
adults. The location was great actually. You had the university to the north and a few restaurants found only a few
2:46
minutes further. However, it was just before noon on November the 13th, 2022
2:52
that this house found on the skirts of Moscow became the epicenter of one of the most violent and brutal stories that
2:59
America had seen in years. 911 location of your emergency. Hi.
3:06
Something is happening. Something's happening. Cannot help. We don't know what. Tell me exactly what's going on.
3:12
Um, one of our one of the roommates has passed out and she was drunk last night
3:17
and she's not waking me up. Okay. Oh, and they saw some man in their house last night. Can I just tell you what
3:24
happened pretty much? What is going on currently? Is someone passed out right now?
3:29
I don't really know, but pretty much at 4:00 a.m. Okay. I need to know what's going on right now. Someone has passed out. Can
3:35
you find that out? Yeah. Oh, come. Come on. Let me You got to go check.
3:40
What's wrong? She's not waking up.
3:46
Yeah. Okay. Hello.
3:51
Is she breathing? No. Okay. I have already sent the ambulance and
3:58
law enforcement. Stay on the line. There's a point here right now. Okay. Okay. I'm going to let you go since he's
4:03
there with you and can help you. Okay. Thank you. Shortly after this terrifying phone call was made, police arrived at the
4:10
residence. From the street, nothing looked wrong or out of place. There was no shattered glass, no signs of forced
4:17
entry, and the curtains were drawn. As they approached the property, some of them even expected that they would only
4:23
be helping someone wake up. But once they were inside, the reality and gravity of it all quickly set in. What
4:30
officers encountered was nothing short of horrific. And that's because this wasn't a single or small medical
4:37
emergency, but was an allout catastrophe. Additional units were called in immediately, and the home
4:44
suddenly changed from a student house into a full-blown crime scene. The home
4:50
was unnaturally still as police officers moved through its narrow hallways, pausing at corners and closed doors and
4:57
announcing themselves into rooms that never answered back. The first grim discovery came on the second floor when
5:04
two students were found inside one of the bedrooms. And as officers continued in their investigation, they found two
5:11
more victims in another bedroom. It was at that moment that they realized that four young students had all had their
5:18
lives ended in the same house across multiple bedrooms and on a single night.
5:23
And so obviously they realized that whatever was going on, this extended far past them or the officers or even
5:31
Moscow. Meanwhile, outside the neighborhood's tone shifted. It is the kind of tension that everyone dreads
5:38
because as police presence grew and the patrol cars arrived and then remained at the property, everyone waiting outside
5:45
knew that this was not going to be just another noise complaint. It was in that moment that one of the officers stepped
5:51
away from the property to speak with one of its surviving roommates. And from this footage, you can tell how horrified
5:58
and shaken Dylan was. All I heard was I heard her go upstairs. I'm like, "Okay, I'm going to go to sleep now cuz she's
6:04
going upstairs." Also, you heard who go upstairs? Kayie and the dog Murphy
6:09
and upstairs to the very top. Yeah, that's where her room is.
6:18
Okay. And then all of a sudden, her walking up, I heard her scream and she ran downstairs cuz she saw someone. That's
6:25
what I'm pretty sure she said. she's someone's here and she scream and just ran downstairs and I called for her name
6:31
but I jumped up and locked my door cuz I was so scared. Um and then and the I
6:37
heard someone in the bathroom and I heard her crying and I heard some guy say that you're going to be okay. I'm going to help you and I kept calling her
6:43
name but she wasn't answering. And then I opened the door for a second and I saw this guy and he was not insanely tall
6:50
but he was wearing all black and like this mask which is covering his forehead and his mouth. And then I locked the
6:55
door and I called and I didn't know what to do. This is at 4. 4 a.m. Yes. Now, Dylan claimed that she'd woken up
7:02
in the middle of the night to sounds that she couldn't quite explain. Movements and voices that all felt a
7:08
little off. It is worth noting, however, that despite the strangeness, she never felt threatened by any of it.
7:15
Apparently, he was dressed all in dark clothing and didn't even acknowledge her presence. He just simply walked by
7:22
towards the exit. It's the kind of encounter that you'd feel very uncomfortable in, especially as a woman.
7:27
But with this being a student house, there could have been a million innocent explanations. And so, she simply walked
7:33
back inside her bedroom and shut her door. But the important part here is that her recollection of that evening
7:39
changed everything about the story at that stage of the investigation. Because not only did it verify that an unknown,
7:45
mysterious man was inside the property on the night that her four friends were murdered, but also that he had acted
7:52
while everyone was fast asleep in bed. And as investigators took a closer look at the crime scene, they realized that
7:58
although clues were in fact sparse, there were a couple that they could indeed work with. But before we jump the
8:05
gun here, who precisely were the Idaho 4? So before answering that question, I'd first like to take you behind the
8:11
scenes here at Coffee House Crime. With the turn of the new year, a lot of us are thinking about returning to work,
8:17
getting back into the swing of things, and of course, New Year's resolutions. But the truth is that a lot of us
8:23
YouTubers don't actually stop over the festive period. And I'm going to let you in on a small secret here about YouTube.
8:30
But by the time Christmas and the festive season has ended, many of us YouTubers actually see a huge dip to our
8:36
AdSense earnings, which makes sense, right? Because everyone's out of their usual routine over Christmas. And while
8:42
they're seeing their family and friends, they're probably focusing on more cozy subjects. So with that in mind, I just
8:48
want to say thank you to all of you who come here week in and week out to help support the channel. And with a natural
8:54
dip over the festive period, this is precisely how our sponsors like today's paid partner ZTO can help keep the
9:01
lights on over quieter moments. So, on the topic of resolutions, what have you
9:06
decided for yourself this year? Is it perhaps pick up a new hobby, maybe go to the gym more regularly, or finally get
9:13
around to looking after your health? Now, personally for me, I think this is probably the year that I finally get
9:18
around to fixing my repetitive strain injury that I picked up at the gym. and ZDOC will definitely help with that. And
9:24
if health is on your list too, then I would love to tell you about them. For those of you who haven't heard of Zukdoc, it's a free website that helps
9:31
you find and book highquality and network doctors, so you can find someone you love. With more than 150,000
9:37
providers across all 50 states, you can search and book providers across more than 200 specialties, including
9:43
dermatology, dentistry, primary care, and eye care. View thousands of verified
9:48
patient reviews to get a real sense of who your doctor is and find one that you actually vibe with. You can also see
9:54
their real-time availability. Click to book instantly and decide in person or video. Appointments made through ZDOC
10:01
typically happen within just 24 to 72 hours of booking. And you can even score sameday appointments, too. So, if you
10:08
are serious about your health, then there is no better resolution than looking after it. And Zukdoc will help
10:13
you find a doctor who listens, understands, and of course supports you. So go to zdoc.com/copyhouse
10:21
to find and instantly book a toprated doctor today. Thank you to Zok for sponsoring this video and thank you to
10:27
you folks for supporting the creators that you care about. And now let's dive into who the Idaho 4 really were.
10:37
As it always goes, they were all just ordinary people before this story became
10:42
well, a story. Much like you and I once were, they were all simply students,
10:47
just caught in the ordinary gravity of college life. So, beginning with Madison Morgan, she was 21 years old at the time
10:55
and was a senior at the University of Idaho studying marketing. friends described her as outgoing and loyal and
11:02
someone who kept people close and made plans easily. This is something we'll come back to towards the end of the
11:08
video, but Madison worked at a local restaurant named the Mad Greek. Having grown up in Idaho, she was nearing the
11:15
end of her college years, and so she was naturally looking ahead after graduation and whatever came next. Her close friend
11:23
Kaye Gonzalez was also 21 years old at the time. Also a senior who was studying
11:28
general studies, she and Madison were described as inseparable. By now, they had known each other for several years
11:35
and would have likely been forever friends. Now, Kaye was only weeks away from graduating and had already accepted
11:42
a job out of state. In fact, she had already even recently moved out of the
11:47
King Road house, but had returned to see her friends. As for the weekend that she was tragically murdered, Kaye was back
11:54
in Moscow to spend time with Madison and also to show her the new car that she had recently purchased. Now, on the
12:01
second floor lived Santa Canodal, who was a 20-year-old junior that was studying marketing at the time.
12:07
Alongside her was her boyfriend, Ethan Chapen, who was also 20 at the time. Ethan was a freshman who was majoring in
12:14
recreation, sport, and tourism management, and was well known on campus for his warmth and friendliness. And
12:21
although he didn't officially live at the King Road House, he spent much of his time here with his girlfriend,
12:26
Santa. Interesting side note here, but both Santa and Madison worked at the same restaurant, and their connection
12:32
was not accidental. This was a house that was shaped by overlapping friendships. Now, you could say that the
12:39
house on King Road was rarely quiet. It wasn't overly drunk or dangerous or
12:44
disorderly, but it definitely was social. Many of their friends would come by without any notice whatsoever. Music
12:51
would play on the porch on most days. And with this many visitors, the noise was kind of inevitable. It is worth
12:58
noting that in the months leading up to November, police had already been called to the address on more than one
13:04
occasion. It wasn't for violence or anything criminal like that, and it was merely just noise complaints. But of
13:11
course, with students being students, a lot of the other neighbors around would lose out on sleep. And as it turns out,
13:17
one of those visits was even captured on police body cam footage. Well, understand that you're responsible
13:22
for the residents. So, whoever else is here, if they have a safe way to get home, you need to kick them out or tell
13:28
them to come inside and be quiet. Cuz the houses that are on this hill all the way around here, we can hear you from
13:34
clear down the road when we were coming up here. We can hear the music and that's I'm so sorry. We're past the point of having polite
13:40
conversations, okay? The neighbors are being kept up. As you can see in this video, officers
13:45
approached the house late at night. The atmosphere was relaxed and Santa, who answered the door, was cooperative,
13:51
apologetic, and even friendly. The officers told Santa that she had to keep it down before then being on their way.
13:58
And from this footage, you can see how chill she and everybody else really was. And so with that said, let's talk about
14:06
the night of November the 12th followed by the morning of November the 13th. It
14:11
was a Saturday, meaning that football was the talk of the town. The University of Idaho Vandals played that afternoon.
14:17
And with it being a home game at the Kibby Dome, it drew in thousands of students. The Vandals would go on to win
14:24
that evening. And so it is no surprise to learn that everyone in the area had a reason to celebrate. Santa and Ethan
14:31
spent their evening at the Sigma Chai fraternity house and friends would later confirm that the two were together for
14:37
the entire night afterwards. It turns out that nothing about their evening stood out and it's reported that the two
14:43
left sometime around 1:45 before then heading back towards the property on
14:48
King Road. Meanwhile, both Kaye and Madison spent their entire night downtown, staying together while they
14:55
moved through their usual spots in the area. They eventually arrived at the Corner Club, which is a bar just off
15:01
Main Street, and once again, a regular stop for them. Both surveillance footage and witness reports placed them here
15:08
until around 1:30 that morning, where they appeared relaxed and with nothing out of the ordinary happening. There was
15:14
nothing to suggest that anything was wrong or a miss either. Though just like the other two, there was no obvious sign
15:21
of drama or issue. When the bar closed, Madison and Kaye walked a short distance towards the Grub Truck, a late night
15:28
food stand that was parked downtown. Just out of coincidence, it turns out that the truck was actually live
15:34
streaming on Twitch at the time. The camera had surveillance over the sidewalk in a wide, grainy view, where
15:40
both Madison and Kaye can eventually be seen appearing on camera while waiting for their food. As you can see, they
15:47
occasionally glance over towards the street. And then at approximately 1:56
15:52
a.m., the two then leave in a taxi, which was heading back toward King Road. Madison and Kaye arrive home just before
16:00
2:00 a.m. And coincidentially, both Santa and Ethan also make it back around the same time,
16:07
and soon enough, all of the lights were out, and the property fell silent at last. Now, for a while, nothing
16:13
happened, and all was peaceful. However, as we know, around 4:00 a.m., all of that changed. It all began when Dylan,
16:20
who was asleep on the second floor, woke up to what sounded like the dog playing upstairs. You see, Murphy the dog
16:27
belonged to Kaye. And of course, Kaye was visiting Madison over the weekend, and all three of them lived above Dylan
16:33
on the third floor. And with this being a student house, noise, even this late at night, wasn't unusual. It wasn't long
16:39
after this encounter that Dylan then heard Kaye say something along the lines of, "There's someone here." And again,
16:46
while that was an odd thing to hear, it didn't register as a danger or a warning at the time. Instead, it sounded casual
16:52
and perhaps even dismissive. A short while later, she then heard even more noise, but this time, it was actually
16:59
coming from the same second floor. She described the sound as crying coming from Sana's room, to which she then
17:05
heard a male voice respond with, "It's okay. I'm going to help you. However, once again, Dylan felt more confused
17:12
than worried, and there was no obvious sign of struggle or shouting going on. And so, after checking her front door
17:18
for the second time, she then headed back to sleep. But after opening her door for the third time, well, what she
17:25
saw would stop her cold because that is when she came face to face with a man who was walking straight towards her.
17:32
Slowly slinking down the hallway. The man was dressed all in black, wore a face mask, and had bushy eyebrows, a
17:38
detail that would later matter. But rather than say or do anything to Dylan, he quite literally ignored her
17:44
existence. Instead, he walked by her and towards the sliding glass door. I mean
17:49
that quite literally, by the way, because this man didn't even acknowledge Dylan. Instead, he just walked right by
17:55
her and then just like that, vanished into the night. Dylan stood frozen as
18:01
the man passed by. Once he was gone, she then shut her door and locked herself
18:06
inside her room. And it turns out that she was not the only person or thing to
18:11
spot something strange that night either. At approximately 4:17 that morning, a security camera, which was
18:18
found less than 50 ft away from the property, captured some rather strange audio. In this footage, you can hear
18:24
what sounds like voices or a whimper, which was then followed by a loud thud and then a dog barking repeatedly.
18:37
It was around the same time that a white Hyundai Elantre was captured making several passes through the neighborhood
18:43
after which the car was seen leaving the area quite rapidly. Moving on to the crime scene in the hours after the
18:50
brutal discovery, investigators searched for clues high and low. Detectives concluded that the killer had actually
18:56
done a very good job in leaving almost nothing behind. But of course, in this
19:02
day and age, there is always something that they can work on. It was on the third floor and where Madison and Kaye
19:08
were found that investigators discovered a tan leather knife sheath on the bed. The sheath was stamped with the markings
19:15
Kabar USMC. And judging by its design, the sheath was designed to stay attached
19:21
to a belt and not left behind at a crime scene. With all of this in mind, the
19:26
sheath was carefully collected and then sent for forensic testing. And when the results came back, it was resounding.
19:33
Located on the metal snap of this sheath was a single male DNA profile. The
19:39
profile wasn't a mixture or degraded in the slightest. Instead, it offered one
19:45
single suspect. As the lab work continued, investigators profiled the neighborhood and asked both far and wide
19:52
for surveillance footage. And thankfully, what they found was movement. Through all of the hours of
19:58
footage they scoured, no surprise, but they would eventually be most interested in the white Hyundai Elantre that we've
20:04
already mentioned before. Now, initially, analysts believed the car to be a 2011 to 2013 model. However, this
20:11
was eventually extended to be as new as 2016. When police asked the community for help in identifying the vehicle,
20:18
their response was overwhelming. We're talking about thousands of tips pouring in with many leads extending into
20:24
Washington, Oregon, Nevada, and even Montana. That was a lot of land for
20:30
police to cover. But I'd like to draw your attention to here, to the nearby town of Pullman, Washington, which can
20:36
be found about 10 mi away from Moscow. Despite being in different states, driving between these two towns only
20:44
takes around 15 minutes. And it turns out that one particular white Hyundai Electra that came from the town of
20:50
Pullman had now come across their sights. The vehicle's records would lead them to a graduate student living in the
20:57
area and his name was Brian Cobberger. And surprisingly, not only did his
21:02
vehicle fit the bill, but when detectives took a closer look into his profile, they realized that his trail
21:09
was not actually subtle at all. In fact, he already had history with Moscow. It
21:14
was in August of 2022 and only a few weeks before the killings that Brian had
21:19
been stopped by Moscow police for a routine traffic violation. Now, at the time, this interaction was quite
21:26
unremarkable. He gave the police officers his ID, answered their questions, and then provided them with
21:32
his phone number. So, when investigators later applied for warrants to obtain historical phone records, they took this
21:39
opportunity to check out his location data. And when they did, well, let's just say that it painted a pretty
21:46
devastating story.
21:51
Surprisingly, it showed that Brian was in the area of King Road at least a dozen times in the months leading up to
21:57
November the 13th, with most of these visits happening late at night or in the early hours of the morning. Of course,
22:04
this was a very strange detail for detectives to realize because Brian had no business in the area. So why was he
22:11
repeatedly traveling to King Road without any purpose or reason? Detectives also realized that between 3
22:17
and 5 on the morning of the murders, Brian's phone stopped connecting to nearby towers altogether. It didn't
22:23
appear near King Road or anywhere else for that matter and was untraceable in a 4G and 5G rich area. In short, the phone
22:31
was decisively turned off for 2 hours that morning over the space where four people were murdered. And of course,
22:38
that wasn't reassuring at all to detectives. If anything, it was incredibly suspicious. And when his
22:44
phone was finally switched on and connected back to the network, it showed Brian traveling southwest away from the
22:50
crime scene, which of course aligned perfectly with the surveillance footage. And all of a sudden, the data and even
22:57
the lack of data was creating a very damning picture.
23:03
Now, if that wasn't enough already, detectives in Pennsylvania would then go on to recover trash from Brian's family
23:10
home. Of course, the main aim here was to try to find DNA that belonged to Brian or his family. And when they
23:16
finally tested trash that belonged to his father, lab analysis showed that the profile was consistent with being the
23:23
biological father of the person whose DNA had been found on the knife sheath.
23:28
All of a sudden, all of these separate articles of evidence which had once floated separately, that being the
23:34
sheath, the car, the DNA, and the phone, was now all coming together. And what initially began as a lone, mysterious
23:41
man walking down a hallway, had now transpired into the actual name of the
23:46
Idaho for killer. So, we know his name, and we know all about his behavior. But
23:52
who precisely is Brian Cobberger? 27 years old at the time, Brian Christopher
23:57
Coberger seemed ordinary enough at first. Of course, minus that death stare because that is not ordinary. Now, on
24:04
the surface, his life appeared to be structured and was directed by his routines, academic goals, and a quiet
24:12
sense of ambition. Born on November the 21st, 1994 and raised in Pennsylvania,
24:17
Brian grew up in a suburban home with his parents and sisters. Family members would later describe his childhood as
24:24
normal and definitely not troubled. He attended local schools, moved through his teenage years without any notable
24:30
drama and always seemed relaxed. People who knew Brian in his earlier life do
24:35
recall his struggles. However, as a teenager, Brian dealt with both weight issues and social isolation. Over time,
24:43
he would eventually lose most of his excess weight and would then become focused on discipline, boxing, running,
24:49
and strict routines. Academically speaking, Brian first earned himself an associate degree before then going on to
24:57
receiving a bachelor's degree in psychology. Strangely enough, his interests would even narrow down towards
25:03
crime, and he then went on to complete a master's degree in, you guessed it, criminal justice. Now, here's the
25:10
interesting part, but it turns out that his coursework focused on criminal behavior, investigative methods, and
25:16
even the mechanics of crime itself. And then in 2022, he enrolled in a PhD
25:22
program in criminology at Washington State University in Pullman. Brian came
25:27
across as both serious and reserved, and although he wasn't known as an extrovert, he was described as sometimes
25:34
confident. Other people would say that he was cold, corrected others during discussions, and would take debate way
25:41
too seriously. Oh, and another interesting side note, but he had also applied for an internship with the
25:47
Pullman Police Department as a data analyst. And although he wasn't accepted into the program, you can quite clearly
25:54
see his intentions. In the days and weeks after the murders, and while Brian was still a free man, people who saw him
26:01
say he appeared quiet and more withdrawn. It was also noted that he attended all classes as usual, continued
26:08
on with his routine, and although a little bit more quiet, his behavior didn't seem much different than before.
26:14
It was almost like nothing big had happened in his life. But little did he know that soon enough he was going to
26:20
come face to face with dozens of armed officers.
26:25
It was on the morning of December the 15th, 2022 that Brian and his father were driving home for the holidays. This
26:33
included a 2300-mile journey from Idaho to Pennsylvania. However, not long into
26:39
the journey, officers would stop them in their tracks, but not for the reason you'd expect. They were initially
26:45
stopped in Hancock County, where an officer pulled the vehicle over for following another one too closely. After
26:52
approaching Brian's window, he handed over his license and his registration without any hesitation. The deputy
26:59
explained the reason for the stop, issued them a warning, and then sent Brian and his father away. However, only
27:05
9 minutes later, officers appeared yet again. Now, at this stage, you might be thinking to yourself that maybe officers
27:12
were finally going to arrest him. However, unfortunately, you'd be wrong. This time, it was an Indiana State
27:18
Police trooper that stopped them for the very same reason as before. But even still, no search was conducted, and once
27:26
again, they were released without a warning. Now, at the time, neither of these stops was unusual or strange, and
27:32
no laws had been broken. So, there was no plausible reason for them to detain Brian. But, of course, these two moments
27:39
stand out, not for what happened, but what didn't happen. You have to remember here that at this stage in the
27:45
investigation, both Brian and his car were under the spotlight. And yet here they were being noted down not once but
27:53
twice before then being allowed to go on their way. However, thankfully less than two weeks later, their journey would end
27:59
in a very different way. By the final week of December, the investigation had gone quiet on the surface. However,
28:06
behind the scenes, investigators were no longer looking for who was responsible, but instead were merely waiting to act
28:13
on it. They already had the outline of the case, the car, the phone data, the timeline, the DNA, and the man
28:20
responsible. And so, in the early hours of December the 30th, 2022, law
28:26
enforcement finally made their move. It was shortly before dawn that a tactical
28:31
team arrived at Brian's family home. Now, according to police reports, they actually found him while he was digging
28:38
through his own family's trash can while wearing latex gloves. Now, for any
28:43
innocent person out there, I don't think that's how you'd spend your typical Friday morning. So, I guess you could
28:49
say that they actually caught him red-handed. Brian was arrested without incident. And when he arrived at the
28:55
police station, he was charged as a fugitive from justice. That being a procedural step that allowed Idaho
29:02
authorities to bring him back across state lines. Simultaneously, search
29:07
warrants were executed on his home, his belongings, and the white Hyundai Elantre that had already traveled
29:13
thousands of miles with him. Detectives would also seize both his phone and his computer, which funnily enough would
29:20
conveniently lead to an entire album of his selfies being released, categorized into selfies that he had taken before
29:27
the murders and after. Speaking of selfies, this one was taken not even 6
29:33
hours after he had murdered four innocent people. I would also like to question why he took so many photos of
29:39
his own butt. Investigators would later state that sections of his browsing history from the weeks leading up to the
29:45
murders were also missing and that absence was extremely abnormal. And as for his mobile phone, well,
29:51
unfortunately, data was sparse. Brian barely kept any contacts in his phone
29:56
book. It was mostly just his mother and father and records showed that they frequently communicated in the days
30:02
after the murders which included both text messaging and phone calls. But beyond that, the authorities have been
30:09
quite careful in what they have publicly released. They have referenced material suggesting rather disturbing interests
30:16
and have also noted that there are patterns of online activity that point towards fixation and control. However,
30:23
most of that evidence has not been disclosed publicly in detail. But what really mattered here is that each
30:29
element on its own would describe a little bit of the story. But when they were all put together, well, that
30:35
created a much stronger picture and one that was far more believable.
30:43
The public's outrage was immediate. And as for Brian's reputation, well, you
30:48
could say that he's become one of the most hated men in America. In fact, he's become so notorious in the recent 2 or 3
30:55
years that I'd be surprised if he hadn't heard of his name before clicking this video. His trial was scheduled for June
31:01
the 30th, 2025. And for about 2 years, everything was building up towards that
31:06
moment. During all that time, they'd been collecting statements, testimonies, and of course, all of the evidence that
31:12
we've already talked about. But the thing is that trial would unfortunately never happen because only a few weeks
31:19
before it was set to begin, Brian accepted a plea agreement. To elaborate here, Brian formally pleaded guilty to
31:26
the murders of Madison, Kaye, Sana, and Ethan, and an associated burglary charge. And with his plea accepted, he
31:34
narrowly avoided any trial whatsoever. However, one of the most frustrating things about this case is that Brian
31:41
refused to comment past his plea deal. What that means is that he didn't provide any explanation or
31:47
acknowledgement beyond the admission itself. And neither could the court ask him to describe what he had done or even
31:53
why. It also meant that because he had pleaded guilty, the state was forced to withdraw its pursuit of the death
32:00
penalty. It basically meant that because Brian had merely said he was guilty, he wouldn't face trial, wouldn't have to
32:06
explain himself, wouldn't have to face his victim's families, and wouldn't have to face death itself. But the good news
32:13
here is that he also waved his right to any future appeals and the legal system accepted certainty without any further
32:20
detail. Meaning there is literally no way he can leave prison. However, on the other side of the coin, it still means
32:26
that we will never know his motive or any intricate details of his crime because unfortunately his right for
32:33
trial in the future was waved away too. At his sentencing, the judge imposed four consecutive life sentences without
32:40
the possibility of parole, ensuring that each victim's life was recognized individually and that there would be no
32:46
mechanism by which Brian could ever be released in the future. He was also given additional time for the burglary
32:53
charge, too, which of course was largely symbolic in the face of his life sentences. During his hearing, family
32:59
and loved ones of the victims addressed the courtroom. They spoke of who the Idaho 4 were before November the 13th
33:06
and how now their futures will never unfold due to the actions of one disturbed individual. Unsurprisingly,
33:14
Brian himself offered no statement of his own and basically kept quiet for the entire thing. And when the hearing was
33:20
over, he was led away in handcuffs to begin the rest of his life in maximum security. And thankfully from this
33:27
moment onwards his movements will be heavily controlled, his contact limited, and his days will be extremely
33:34
repetitive. His life won't be easy, that's for sure.
33:39
Not that it deserves to be, or quite frankly that he even deserves one. As you can likely imagine, his plea
33:46
agreement did nothing to bring relief. In fact, for some people, it actually kind of felt unfinished. By removing the
33:53
death penalty and requiring no explanation, his agreement left dozens of questions unanswered. Of course, as a
34:00
result, the full story would never be told in court. And I'm still left wondering here, why that house? Why did
34:07
he target those students? And what truly happened in those final minutes?
34:13
Tragically, we will never know. Okay, as far as the factual information goes,
34:18
this is where the story ends. But before I finish today, I would love to talk about the credible speculation that
34:25
we've seen. As far as motive or direction is concerned, many people believe that Brian may have been
34:30
targeting Madison, whose bedroom was located on the third floor. I would like to highlight that there is no proof that
34:36
the two had any personal relationship or even knew each other. However, Brian's movements do assume that maybe he was
34:44
targeting her. The reason that some people believe this is that when intruding the property, he bypassed most
34:50
of the rooms in the house and went straight to her bedroom. It is also the same room where Brian's knife sheath was
34:56
found. But the problem for Brian is that unexpectedly Madison's friend Kaye was
35:02
also there at the time, which of course would have shifted his actions entirely. Mobile phone data would also suggest
35:08
that Sana, who was on the second floor, was also awake on her phone shortly before the murders, and that her room
35:15
sat along the likely path that Brian would have had to take to leave. This means that both SA and Ethan would have
35:22
likely been unintentional witnesses that Brian would have likely wanted to silence after murdering both Madison and
35:28
Kaye. And with the speed in which Brian left the property and the sheath left behind, many believe that the situation
35:36
got out of hand and then he panicked. And so if we were to believe these speculations, we would assume that Brian
35:43
had broken into the property with the objective of targeting Madison, panicked when he realized that she wasn't alone,
35:49
murdered two innocent women as a result, and then doubled that to four when he realized that he couldn't leave any
35:56
witnesses behind. Speaking of speculation, there are many thoughts and feelings around the Mad Greek, which of
36:02
course is the restaurant where both Madison and SA worked. In the early stages of this investigation, there were
36:09
some media reports that suggested that maybe Brian had visited the restaurant in the weeks and months leading up to
36:15
the murders. And of course, this opened the doorway to possibilities of how Brian had maybe become aware of Madison
36:22
or even Sana. The restaurant's owner has publicly denied recognizing Brian and
36:28
stated that neither she nor any of her staff ever recall him being there. In addition to this, law enforcement has
36:34
never confirmed any interaction between him and the victims at the restaurant. And no evidence has ever been released
36:41
to support the claim either. And so as it stands, and as far as we know, the whole Mad Greek connection remains
36:47
unverified. And all of that is despite this image right here, which is an image released by law enforcement showing a
36:54
raw data extract taken from a Google review. Anyway, that is as much as I would like to speculate. And I'm going
37:01
to wrap this one up by remembering who the Idaho four were because their lives matter far more than the person who took
37:08
them. Madison Mogan was more than just a name tied to a case. She was a friend
37:14
who showed up, a co-orker who made work easy, and a daughter who stayed close to
37:19
home even when she was planning her future. Family and friends alike miss her tremendously, and the void that she
37:26
is left behind will likely never heal. This is the same for Kaye Gonzaleves,
37:31
who was a true friend with an honest path ahead. She had plans already forming, a new job waiting, and a life
37:38
that was only beginning to open outwards. She loved fiercely, spoke openly, and returned to Moscow that
37:45
weekend for only one simple reason, to lovingly spend time with one of her friends who had become an important part
37:52
of her life. Sana Kenodal was known for her energy and her humor. And her
37:57
friends remember her for the way that she filled a room without even trying. She balanced work, school, and
38:03
relationships responsibly and still made time and space for happiness. Ethan was
38:08
described as kind beyond measure and made people feel included without effort. On the night that he was
38:14
murdered, he was staying with the person that he loved in a house that he felt safe in and in a town that always was.
38:22
As for the house on King Road, it remained vacant for a long time. But over the weeks and then months and then
38:29
years that it remained empty, it basically became an ominous ghost in the area, reminding people and the town of
38:36
the horrors that it held. And so it is no surprise to learn that eventually it was decided to be torn down as a matter
38:44
of respect. Now only open ground remains in its space, and it's not clear if
38:50
anything will ever be built on top again.
38:56
In the same way that we finished last week's video, I always find it fascinating when a building is left behind. Not only for what it stood for
39:03
before the murders, but also how it transformed in the process. I think in this case, it absolutely was the right
39:10
decision to demolish the house. Because unfortunately, those four walls have experienced so much pain. And that,
39:16
folks, is the case of the Idaho 4, at least as it currently stands in January of 2026. Of course, with Brian not
39:24
sharing much of his own motive or story, there is still potential for more information to come out in the future.
39:30
We can only hope that he does so to bring closure to the victim's families. Before I go, I'd love to know what you
39:36
think about this case because, of course, it is quite the notorious one, so I'm sure you have your own opinion.
39:43
As always, please share your thoughts in the comment section down below. I really do appreciate the feedback, too. And
39:48
thank you again to ZuckDoc for sponsoring this video. Go to zdoc.com/coffthouse crime to find and instantly book a
39:54
toprated doctor today. If you'd like to follow me on social media, you can go to my Instagram, Facebook, or Spotify, all
40:00
under the name of Coffee House Crime. But of course, YouTube is my main home base. Anyway, folks, as you can probably
40:07
tell, my voice is absolutely shot today. So, I'm going to end it here. I'll see you again very shortly for another
40:13
video, likely next week. But until that moment arrives, remember to look after yourselves and each other. And of
40:19
course, stay safe and stay curious. Thank you and goodbye.