Welcome to Cruise News, your daily update on
everything happening at sea. Visit CruiseNews
.io to see today's stories and sign up for email
alerts. You know, when we look at cruise brochures
or scroll through Instagram, we see a very specific
script. The perfect sunset, the calm seas. Exactly.
It's the captain clinking glasses with guests,
the itinerary that runs like a Swiss watch. That
is the dream we buy. It is. It is the polished
marketing version of what is, you know, a very
complex industrial operation. Exactly. But today
we're going to tear up that script. We're doing
a deep dive into what happens when the industry
goes off script. Right. Because when you are
on a floating city in the middle of the ocean,
off script can mean anything from a computer
algorithm kicking you off the ship. to a winter
storm trapping you in a terminal. To, in some
cases, a federal investigation taking place behind
sealed doors. It's a fascinating mix today. We
usually talk about the fun stuff, the water slides
and buffets. Sure, but the reality of running
these massive vessels is that they are incredibly
fragile ecosystems. They rely on perfect timing,
perfect headcount, and perfect legal clarity.
And when one of those things breaks... The vacation
changes instantly. We have three stories that
perfectly illustrate this breakdown first, what
I'd call the good kind of disruption, if you're
flexible enough to take it. Royal Caribbean is
currently offering to pay people a significant
amount of money not to sail because their ships
are too full. Which sounds like a dream until
you read the fine print. Always the fine print.
Then we have the bad disruption. We're tracking
a logistical nightmare in the mid -Atlantic right
now, where winter storms are turning terminals
in Baltimore and Norfolk into, well, chaotic
waiting rooms. Yeah not a good scene. And finally
we have to touch on the serious reality. We're
looking at a major update or I guess a major
non -update regarding a homicide aboard the Carnival
Horizon. It is a heavy topic but it sheds a lot
of light on how justice works or maybe doesn't
work when a tragedy happens in international
waters. It is a lot to unpack so let's dive right
in. I want to start with this email from Royal
Caribbean. This is about the oasis of the seas.
for the sailing coming up on February 7, 2026,
out of Fort Lauderdale. A massive ship. How many
people are we talking about? Well, the Oasis
class redefined the industry. You're looking
at over 5 ,600 passengers at double occupancy.
If every single bed is full, so kids and pull
-out couches, upper berths, you could be at nearly
6 ,800 people. So, guests booked on this sailing
open their inbox and see a voluntary cancellation
offer. It basically says, we messed up, we sold
too many tickets, please don't come. Essentially,
yes. They are offering a 100 % refund of everything
you paid. That includes non -refundable deposits,
which is rare. Plus, they're offering a future
cruise credit, an FCC, worth 50 % of your cruise
fare. And what about flights and hotels? They'll
even reimburse non -refundable travel costs for
things like that you've already booked. OK, let's
pause there. Because if I'm a listener holding
a ticket for this cruise, my brain immediately
goes to, I just made a 50 % profit for sitting
on my couch. It feels like free money. It does.
But knowing the cruise industry, that word fair
is a slippery word. It is the most important
definition in the contract. This is the aha moment
for the listener. Your cruise fare is not the
total amount you are charged. Walk us through
that math. Okay, let's say you paid $3 ,000 total
for a balcony stateroom. You assume your 50 %
bonus credit will be $1 ,500. Right. But that
$3 ,000 total includes port taxes, government
fees, prepaid gratuities, maybe a Wi -Fi package,
or travel insurance. All the add -ons. All the
add -ons. The actual base fare, the revenue that
goes to the cruise line for the cabin itself,
might only be, say, $1 ,800 of that total. Oh,
wow. So the bonus credit is calculated on the
$1 ,800, not the $3 ,000. Exactly. So instead
of a $1 ,500 credit, you're getting a $900 credit.
Which is still a good deal. It is still a good
deal. plus 900 for a future trip, but it is not
the windfall people think it is. You know, there
are restrictions on when you can use it. There
are. You have to use that credit on a sailing
that departs by February 7, 2027. You have exactly
one year. 365 days. Right. And if your job doesn't
let you take vacation next year, or if you have
a baby on the way, that credit could expire and
become worthless. That is a crucial detail. Yeah.
But why is Royal Caribbean doing this? Did someone
just, you know... Hit an extra zero on the booking
computer? No, it's intentional. It's called inventory
management. It is the exact same logic airlines
use. OK. They have decades of data that say,
for a February sailing out of Florida, 5 % of
people usually cancel last minute. People get
the flu. They miss flights. They have family
emergency. So they sell more cabins than they
have. They sell 105 % of the cabins, banking
on that 5 % drop off. But in 2026, people aren't
dropping off. Exactly. Post -COVID travel habits
have shifted. People are committing. Cancellation
rates are at historic lows. So when everyone
actually shows up, the math breaks. And this
is better than the alternative. Oh, much better.
Paying people to stay home voluntarily is much
cheaper and better PR than involuntarily denying
them boarding. Which is basically dragging them
off, kicking and screaming. Well, not quite.
But we saw it happen with the quantum of the
seas in Brisbane back in November 2023. Oh, I
remember that. Guests showed up at the terminal,
luggage in hand, excitement at peak levels, and
were told at the check -in desk, sorry, no room
at the inn. That is a nightmare. I can't imagine
standing at the pier with my kids and being turned
away. It was a disaster. And in that case, because
it was involuntary, the compensation was actually
worse. They got a full refund, but only a 25
% future credit. So they've learned their lesson.
Royal Caribbean learned from that. Now they try
to solve the problem a week in advance with these
volunteer offers. It's almost gamified, isn't
it? The source mentioned you have to fill out
a survey and then wait to see if you get picked.
Yes, it is an opt -in situation. You raise your
hand, but you aren't guaranteed to be chosen.
So what happens then? If not enough people volunteer,
they might send a second email with a sweeter
offer, maybe extra onboard credit. But if too
many people volunteer, their algorithm kicks
in again. And who do they pick? They will pick
the passengers who paid the lowest fares to stay
home. They want to keep the big spenders on the
ship. That's fascinating. So even when they are
apologizing, they're optimizing revenue. Always.
A cruise ship is a business first, a vacation
second. So for the listener, if you get one of
these emails, do the math on the base fare, check
your calendar for next year, and realize you're
entering a negotiation with a very smart computer.
Precisely. Don't be blinded by the percentage
sign. All right, let's shift gears. We've talked
about too many people. Now let's talk about too
much weather. If you are near the mid -Atlantic
coast right now, you know it is nasty out there.
It is a classic February winter storm system.
And for Carnival, it is causing some significant
headaches in Baltimore and Norfolk. Well, the
Carnival pride in Baltimore and the Carnival
sunshine in Norfolk. Let's start with the pride.
OK, a spirit class ship, usually very reliable.
But this past Sunday, February 8th, it was not
having a good time. What happened? The ship was
delayed, returning to port by five hours. The
seas were around 15 feet and the winds were gusting.
But the ship can handle that, can't it? Oh, the
ship can handle the waves. Yeah. The problem
was the pilot boat couldn't get to the ship.
Explain that for a second. Why does a massive
cruise ship need a tiny boat to dock? It's maritime
law and safety. A local expert captain, the pilot,
has to board the ship to navigate the specific
channels of the harbor. Right. They usually jump
from a small boat onto the cruise ship while
both are moving. If the seas are too rough, that
transfer is deadly. So the pilot stays home and
the cruise ship has to do circles in the ocean
until the weather calms down. So the pride is
five hours late. That doesn't sound catastrophic.
Why is that such a big deal? Because a cruise
terminal is a flow through facility, not a waiting
room. Right. You have 2 ,500 people trying to
get off the ship with thousands of suitcases.
And you have another 2 ,500 people in the parking
lot trying to get on. And you just compress their
turnaround window by five hours. Exactly. And
those two groups collide. I can visualize the
chaos. Carnival sent out alerts telling people,
do not arrive early. They did. They shifted the
check -in windows. If your arrival time was noon,
your new time was 5 PM. But push yourself in
the passenger's shoes. Yep. checked out of your
hotel at 11 a .m. It is 35 degrees and raining
in Baltimore. You have your luggage. Where do
you go for six hours? You go to the terminal
anyway, which is exactly what they don't want.
Exactly. And then you have the bottleneck at
customs. The agents can't process the new passengers
until the old ones are completely cleared out.
It just becomes gridlock. And I read that this
spilled over onto the ship itself. They had to
scrap the dining schedule. They had no choice.
Usually dinner is a choreographed ballet, early
seating, late seating. Right. But because boarding
was happening during dinnertime, the galley couldn't
track who was on board. They just threw open
the dining room doors. Open seating for everyone.
Which sounds democratic. But in reality, it means
long lines, confused waiters, and a very stressful
start to the vacation. It sets a frantic tone
for the whole trip. And the Carnival Sunshine
in Norfolk had it even worse. Worse. The port
actually closed on February 7th. The ship couldn't
dock at all. So it was delayed a full day. Yes.
It arrived on Sunday, February 8th. So if you
were booked on that cruise, your eight -night
vacation instantly became a seven -night vacation.
Oof. That hurts. Do they get that day back? They
get a prorated refund. So you get one -eighth
of your fare back. But you can't get back the
time. And the itinerary is ruined. Where were
they headed? They were supposed to go to Half
Moon Cay, Grand Turk, and Amber Cove. When you
lose 24 hours, you have to cut a port or burn
a massive amount of fuel to sail faster. And
it seems like the sunshine is constantly battling
the weather. It is a pattern. This is the third
consecutive voyage for sunshine impacted by weather.
They had to skip Bimini on the last trip. So
this is a risk of sailing from those ports in
winter. It really highlights a specific risk.
When you choose a home port like Norfolk or Baltimore
in the winter, you are gambling. You save money
on airfare by driving to the port, sure, but
you are at the mercy of the North Atlantic Ocean.
It just challenges the idea that these ships
run on a schedule like trains. We think they
are invincible, but one's gorm system throws
thousands of people's plans into a blender. And
it connects back to the overbooking story. In
both cases, the cruise line is trying to maximize
efficiency. The ships are scheduled to arrive
in the morning and leave in the afternoon. Zero
buffer. There is zero buffer. When nature intervenes
or an algorithm fails, the system breaks down
very quickly. Those are logistical issues, annoying,
expensive, but ultimately just travel headaches.
I want to move to our third story now, which
is much more serious. This is a story that has
been developing quietly for years, and it touches
on the very real, very complex legal environment
at sea. Yes, we need to talk about the investigation
into the death of Anna Kepner aboard the Carnival
Horizon. For those who haven't followed this,
can you give us the background? This goes back
to November 2022. It does. Anna Kepner was just
18 years old. She was a high school senior from
Titusville, Florida. And by all accounts, she
was an incredible young woman, a cheerleader.
She planned to join the Navy. She wanted to be
a canine officer. And she was on a family vacation
on the Carnival Horizon. She was. And midway
through the trip, on November 7th, 2022, she
was found dead in her cabin. And the cause of
death. The medical examiner later determined
it was homicide by mechanical asphyxiation. She
was found concealed under a bed in the cabin
she was sharing with her stepbrother. Her stepbrother,
who was a minor at the time. He was 16 years
old. And that detail, his age, is what turns
this from a tragic news story into a very complex
lesson on maritime law. We were recording this
in February 2026. It has been nearly four years.
We just got an update this week, but the update
is mysterious. It is. A hearing took place in
federal court in Miami just this past week, but
it was a sealed hearing. What does that mean,
sealed? The doors were locked, the docket number,
the case file ID is sealed, the press and the
public were barred from entering. If this happened
on land, say, in a house in Orlando, we would
know everything. There would be arrest records,
probable cause affidavits, public court dates.
Why is this so secretive? Two main reasons. First,
jurisdiction. Because the crime happened in international
waters, local Florida police have no authority.
This falls to the FBI. It is a federal case.
And the second reason? The suspect's age. The
Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention Act
provides massive privacy protections for minors
in the federal system. Even though he's an adult
now? Even though the stepbrother is now an adult,
the legal proceedings relate to a crime allegedly
committed when he was 16. The federal system
defaults to secrecy for juveniles, unlike many
state courts. But four years. That seems like
an incredibly long time for an investigation.
Why is it moving so slowly? This is where the
at -sea factor complicates everything. I was
reading some analysis from Scott Robinson, a
maritime defense lawyer. He isn't involved in
this specific case, but he explained the logistical
nightmare of a shipboard crime. He mentioned
the sheer number of people, right? Exactly. He
said... There are thousands of people on the
cruise ship. Think about it. If a crime happens
in a neighborhood, the witnesses stay in the
neighborhood. Right. On a ship, you have 4 ,000
potential witnesses who all disembark on Saturday
and fly home to 50 different states and 10 different
countries. So the FBI has to track them down
one by one. Precisely. And they have to be meticulous.
You have CCTV footage from hundreds of cameras
to review. You have a crime scene, a cabin that
might have been cleaned by stewards before the
crime was discovered. It's a huge undertaking.
So the delay is actually a sign that they're
trying to do it right. That was Robinson's point.
The burden of proof in federal court is incredibly
high. It is better for the prosecutors to take
four years and build an airtight case than to
rush it and have it thrown out on a technicality.
It is just devastating to think about the families
involved. You have the victim, Anna, who had
her whole life ahead of her, and you have this
complex family dynamic. Court records show custody
disputes, mentions of the stepbrother being in
a facility in therapy. It is a tragedy on every
level. It is, and it highlights a reality we
rarely discuss. When you step onto a cruise ship,
you are leaving the legal protections and processes
of your home state. You're entering a different
zone. A legal island, essentially. Exactly. You
are in a place where the FBI has to fly out to
meet the ship, where the investigation happens
behind closed doors, and where justice can move
at a glacial pace. It is a stark contrast to
the front -and -sun image of cruising. It definitely
changes how I look at the contract of carriage
that we all click agree on without reading. We
all do it. I do it. The track dictates everything
from your refund rights when the algorithm overbooks
you to your compensation when the weather delays
you to your legal recourse if a tragedy strikes.
If we connect these three stories, the Oasis
Overbooking, the Pride Delay, and the Horizon
Investigation, what is the common thread for
you? Isolation. A cruise ship is a contained
city. When the algorithm fails, you can't just
walk to another hotel. You are stranded at the
pier. You are trapped in the terminal. And when
a crime happens, you are in a legal jurisdiction
that operates completely separately from the
normal world. That is a really powerful way to
put it. We love the isolation when it means disconnecting
from work and sipping a cocktail. We call it
an escape. Right. But when things go off script,
that escape becomes a vulnerability. You realize
that you have surrendered a massive amount of
control to the cruise line, to the captain, and
to maritime law. It's a sobering reality check.
It doesn't mean we stop cruising, but maybe we
cruise with our eyes a little more open. Exactly.
Understand the risks. Read the fine print on
the volunteer offers. Buy the travel insurance
for the weather delays. And understand that you
are entering a unique environment where the rules
of land don't always apply. Before we go, I want
to leave the listener with a thought to chew
on. We accept refunds for overbooked flights,
and we accept rain delays for baseball games.
We understand those systems. But when a cruise
goes off script, we feel uniquely helpless. It
raises the question, when we step onto that gangway,
do we fully understand how much autonomy we are
trading for convenience? Are we prepared for
what happens when the floating city stops working?
Thanks for listening to Cruise News. Visit CruiseNews
.io to catch up on the latest updates and sign
up for free email alerts.